The Pieman VC & Italian Catering: Experience Exceptional Pizza and Catering in Valley Cottage

The pizza here is top-notch — always fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Beyond the amazing food, the service is consistently friendly and fast. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, the staff makes you feel genuinely welcome and appreciated. Definitely one of the best spots in the area for quality pizza and excellent customer service. Special shoutout to Mairead — she’s the best!

Friendly welcoming staff that takes the time to help you choose an order. Food is delicious, I had a vodka pizza and banana bread dessert and they were so good. I just had a craving for pizza and spotted this place on my way home and it was worth the visit. This is definitely one of those places that you may end emptying your wallet, because of the quality of the food and the sweet staff that are always willing to help. I took off one star due to the pizza being pretty salty which would make it difficult with people that need to pay attention to their sodium and the fact that it's very expensive since you are paying 13 dollars just for the pizza and 2 dollars for each topping which will add up if you're very hungry or with a group. Shout out to the owner Austin for being such a sweet heart and taking the time to recommend me some delicious food and hiring such amazing staff. I see you and appreciate you.

I used to go to this place as a kid. Decided to give it a chance as an adult: Overall, loved the atmosphere- music felt very millennial or at least that’s what the jukebox was playing? Regardless, I appreciated it as I am a millennial. The meatballs were tender, the sauce was fresh and didn’t give me heart burn which it’s rare red sauce doesn’t give me heartburn. Will definitely be ordering the meatballs again The garlic knots were made from the dough of zeppolis which was interesting. The garlic butter was so yummy! Really phenomenal garlic butter mixture. The 10” pizza margarita leaves something to be desired. Maybe more cheese?? Got two cocktails- the passion fruit cocktail was about 11 bucks and it was very strong. I couldn’t handle it !

My son received his first communion on Mother's Day and I was at a loss for how to best celebrate considering the craziness of the day. After a delicious family meal at Pieman, I partnered with Austin on ideas to host a luncheon for about 15 people the day of his communion -- and I'm beyond glad I did. Austin was excited, knowledgeable, and flexible. She openly shared ideas on how to improve our experience and didn't break a sweat when a few people changed their RSVP day-of. I dropped off balloons and decorations the night before and everything was set up and looking beautiful when we walked in. White table linens were ordered to provide a bit more of a refined look. Food was delicious (as always), service was wonderful and everyone had a great time. Highly recommend considering Pieman for your upcoming event!

First time eating here and it was a pick up order mind you, yet the food was so good! It was reasonably priced, ready within fifteen minutes and the flavors were divine! Love their house sauce and their bread knots. Looking forward to ordering from here again and hope to corral my teens to come and in at the restaurant.

Pieman is a great spot to grab some thin crust, bar style pizza. They've got some unique flavors like the Korean White hot, and the Garlic Knots are awesome. Highly recommend them! This post was made in connection with a Toast Promotion

I love eating at the pie man. The atmosphere is adorable and warm and welcoming and the bar is filled with friendly people and they have entertainment which is not too loud and just perfect and the service is great and then to top it all off our salads were fresh and not from a bag and the pizza is absolutely spectacular. Super thin crust and perfectly made. What a treat.